Skip to main content
Assets
International Business Machines logo
IBM.NYSE
International Business Machines
Information Technology · IT Consulting & Other Services

Global technology and consulting company providing integrated solutions leveraging AI, cloud, and data platforms.

HQ: United StatesListed: United States

Historical AI Opinions

Audit every published iPulse AI forecast batch and immutable historical research document for International Business Machines.

International Business Machines Corporation (IBM.NYSE) AI OPINIONS & ADVISOR ANALYSIS

Read and compare the 14 individual AI Advisor deep-dive reports, including their forecast paths, ratings, price targets, and reasoning.

Updated on 20 September 2026Deep analysis 20 September 2026

25 min readAudit All Past Forecasts

1. Investment Thesis — Base Case

IBM's case has narrowed to one question: is the annuity real? The evidence says largely yes — 80% recurring software, $24.6bn growing 8%, a dividend unbroken since 1916 — while the violence sits in a mainframe cycle that borrowed Q2 from Q1 and a consulting book that has stopped growing [9][3]. The 2026 de-rating from roughly $330 to $230 priced the disappointment thoroughly but left the annuity underpaid. Base case: mid-single-digit revenue growth, high-single-digit , a broadly flat multiple, and total return led by cash distribution rather than re-rating.

  • TTM of $13.6bn on a $219bn market cap yields 6.2%, comfortably funding a 2.9% dividend.
  • Holding roughly 19-20x earnings while compounds mid-to-high single digits supports about 40% price appreciation by 2031.
  • That implies near $306bn market capitalisation on roughly $85bn revenue — 3.6x sales, below software-heavy peer multiples.

Historical prices and published forecast

Historical prices and published forecastObserved prices and the selected advisor's published projection share a split-adjusted price basis. Prices after the forecast start are later observations, not information known at publication. Forecasts are uncertain. Values in USD.96.3157.41218.52279.64340.75Sep 2021Mar 2024Sep 2026Mar 2029Sep 2031Forecast starts
  • Observed price
  • Published advisor forecast
Observed prices and the selected advisor's published projection share a split-adjusted price basis. Prices after the forecast start are later observations, not information known at publication. Forecasts are uncertain. Values in USD.
View chart values
Historical prices and published forecast — published chart values
SeriesDateValue (USD)
Observed price2021-09-16130
Observed price2021-10-09136
Observed price2021-10-15137
Observed price2021-10-26120
Observed price2021-11-19117
Observed price2021-12-06121
Observed price2021-12-12122
Observed price2022-01-04138
Observed price2022-01-21130
Observed price2022-02-02137
Observed price2022-02-08138
Observed price2022-02-25123
Observed price2022-03-09125
Observed price2022-03-26131
Observed price2022-04-12126
Observed price2022-04-24137
Observed price2022-05-05138
Observed price2022-05-17133
Observed price2022-06-03141
Observed price2022-06-15136
Observed price2022-07-02139
Observed price2022-07-25129
Observed price2022-08-06131
Observed price2022-08-18138
Observed price2022-08-29130
Observed price2022-09-21124
Observed price2022-10-14120
Observed price2022-10-20129
Observed price2022-10-26134
Observed price2022-11-18148
Observed price2022-12-11150
Observed price2022-12-17142
Observed price2022-12-29141
Observed price2023-01-09145
Observed price2023-01-21141
Observed price2023-02-01135
Observed price2023-02-19133
Observed price2023-03-14125
Observed price2023-03-20124
Observed price2023-04-06131
Observed price2023-04-18127
Observed price2023-05-11122
Observed price2023-05-17125
Observed price2023-06-09136
Observed price2023-06-14137
Observed price2023-06-26132
Observed price2023-07-13134
Observed price2023-07-31144
Observed price2023-08-17141
Observed price2023-09-03148
Observed price2023-09-21148
Observed price2023-10-02141
Observed price2023-10-20139
Observed price2023-10-31145
Observed price2023-11-06147
Observed price2023-11-29157
Observed price2023-12-17161
Observed price2023-12-28163
Observed price2024-01-03160
Observed price2024-01-26187
Observed price2024-02-01187
Observed price2024-02-18183
Observed price2024-03-01189
Observed price2024-03-12197
Observed price2024-03-30190
Observed price2024-04-22182
Observed price2024-05-09167
Observed price2024-05-21173
Observed price2024-06-01166
Observed price2024-06-19173
Observed price2024-06-25172
Observed price2024-07-18183
Observed price2024-08-04188
Observed price2024-08-16194
Observed price2024-08-21196
Observed price2024-09-14213
Observed price2024-09-19218
Observed price2024-10-13234
Observed price2024-10-18230
Observed price2024-10-30205
Observed price2024-11-16210
Observed price2024-12-04233
Observed price2024-12-15229
Observed price2025-01-07221
Observed price2025-01-13222
Observed price2025-02-05257
Observed price2025-02-17261
Observed price2025-03-06251
Observed price2025-03-18250
Observed price2025-04-04237
Observed price2025-04-10228
Observed price2025-05-03246
Observed price2025-05-09250
Observed price2025-05-20264
Observed price2025-06-07272
Observed price2025-06-30295
Observed price2025-07-06293
Observed price2025-07-29262
Observed price2025-08-04252
Observed price2025-08-15239
Observed price2025-09-02242
Observed price2025-09-25271
Observed price2025-10-12277
Observed price2025-10-24297
Observed price2025-10-29310
Observed price2025-11-16296
Observed price2025-12-09309
Observed price2025-12-21303
Observed price2026-01-13303
Observed price2026-01-18293
Observed price2026-01-30305
Observed price2026-02-16263
Observed price2026-02-22236
Observed price2026-03-06258
Observed price2026-04-09231
Observed price2026-04-15250
Observed price2026-04-21252
Observed price2026-05-14219
Observed price2026-05-20227
Observed price2026-06-01318
Observed price2026-06-18250
Observed price2026-07-05299
Observed price2026-07-23208
Observed price2026-08-09236
Observed price2026-08-26238
Observed price2026-09-01232
Observed price2026-09-13248
Observed price2026-09-24227
Observed price2026-09-25226
Published advisor forecast2026-09-18230
Published advisor forecast2026-12-18239
Published advisor forecast2027-03-18244
Published advisor forecast2027-06-18246
Published advisor forecast2027-09-18253
Published advisor forecast2027-12-18258
Published advisor forecast2028-03-18261
Published advisor forecast2028-06-18266
Published advisor forecast2028-09-18256
Published advisor forecast2028-12-18266
Published advisor forecast2029-03-18274
Published advisor forecast2029-06-18276
Published advisor forecast2029-09-18282
Published advisor forecast2029-12-18290
Published advisor forecast2030-03-18282
Published advisor forecast2030-06-18290
Published advisor forecast2030-09-18296
Published advisor forecast2030-12-18305
Published advisor forecast2031-03-18308
Published advisor forecast2031-06-18314
Published advisor forecast2031-09-18320

2. Scenarios & Signals

Bull case

The bull case activates when Q3 and Q4 2026 prove the mainframe decline was arithmetic, not autopsy. Normalised Z comparisons restore infrastructure growth and drag high-margin transaction-processing software with them; software holds the guided 6-8% range; delivers the promised increase. That combination rebuilds credibility just as policy rates ease from 2028, lifting the multiple on long-duration cash flows. Add early Starling-era quantum contracts and the market re-rates IBM from to .

Bear case

The bear case activates if the 42% Z collapse proves secular rather than cyclical. Losing mainframe revenue also strips the attached transaction-processing software, so group margins deteriorate precisely as $62bn of debt refinances at 5%-plus coupons. Acquisition goodwill from the $10.5bn 2026 spend then faces impairment, are squeezed to protect the dividend, and quantum reads as value destruction. The shares compress toward low-teens earnings multiples and stay there.

Current crowd narrative

The tape says " with a dividend." After a 30% year-to-date drawdown to July and a 12-month total return of -11.1% against the S&P 500's +16.3% [3][2], the crowd has concluded IBM's AI narrative was a mainframe pull-forward in disguise. The anchoring bias is the July guidance cut. Consensus labels disguise dispersion: targets span $174 to $350 [1], Baird neutral at $230 against BofA at $330 [4].

Alpha-gap assessment

The crowd modestly underestimates these shares. The evidence chain: Q1 Z revenue +51%, Q2 Z -42%, management conceding pull-forward [5][3] — yet the de-rating punished the entire enterprise, including an $24.6bn software annuity growing 8% with 80% [9]. The blind spot is treating a hardware timing artifact as a structural verdict. At 20.4x trailing earnings and a 6.2% free-cash-flow yield, the price embeds near-zero credit for mainframe normalisation and none whatsoever for state-financed quantum. Offsetting that: flat first-half cash flow and $62bn of debt justify part of the discount.

Convergence catalyst

Q3 2026 results in late October are the first hard test: a Z decline that moderates rather than deepens, plus reiteration of the 4-5% constant-currency guide, invalidates the secular-decline reading. The first observable sign of repricing is infrastructure revenue turning less negative alongside software holding the 6-8% guided range.

Complete advisor preview locked

Unlock this report and every AI Advisor

Sign in to check your access, or upgrade to the Base plan to read this report and open every advisor.