Skip to main content
Assets
e.l.f. Beauty logo
ELF.NYSE
e.l.f. Beauty
Consumer Staples · Personal Care Products
e.l.f. Beauty, Inc., a beauty company, provides cosmetics and skin care products worldwide. The company offers eye, lip, face, paw, and skin care products. It offers products under the e.l.f. Cosmetics, e.l.f.MoreShow less
HQ: United StatesListed: United States

Historical AI Opinions

Audit every published iPulse AI forecast batch and immutable historical research document for e.l.f. Beauty.

ELF Beauty Inc (ELF.NYSE) AI OPINIONS & ADVISOR ANALYSIS

Read and compare the 14 individual AI Advisor deep-dive reports, including their forecast paths, ratings, price targets, and reasoning.

Updated on 20 September 2026Deep analysis 20 September 2026

25 min readAudit All Past Forecasts

1. Investment Thesis — Base Case

The central tension is that e.l.f. is two businesses wearing one ticker: a mature, price-elastic mass core defending shelf against imitators and its own 2025 price increase, and a founder-brand machine monetising rhode through Sephora's global footprint. Over five years rhode's international rollout and post-China sourcing should carry consolidated growth from guided 18-20% in FY2027 down toward low-teens, with holding near 21% as marketing absorbs the tariff relief. Shareholders capture that through earnings compounding and buyback, not — the re-rating from $52 already happened.

  • FY2027 guided of $401-407M on $1.94-1.97B sales implies roughly 21% margin, near flat year over year.
  • At $96.40 shares trade at about 27x guided adjusted of $3.53 and roughly 15-16x EV/.
  • Cross-check: a $5.76B market capitalisation equals about 2.9x FY2027 guided sales, unexceptional for a mid-teens .

Historical prices and published forecast

Historical prices and published forecastObserved prices and the selected advisor's published projection share a split-adjusted price basis. Prices after the forecast start are later observations, not information known at publication. Forecasts are uncertain. Values in USD.2.1659.14116.11173.09230.07Sep 2021Mar 2024Sep 2026Mar 2029Sep 2031Forecast starts
  • Observed price
  • Published advisor forecast
Observed prices and the selected advisor's published projection share a split-adjusted price basis. Prices after the forecast start are later observations, not information known at publication. Forecasts are uncertain. Values in USD.
View chart values
Historical prices and published forecast — published chart values
SeriesDateValue (USD)
Observed price2021-09-1630.1
Observed price2021-09-2029.0
Observed price2021-10-0630.1
Observed price2021-10-1829.3
Observed price2021-10-3032.5
Observed price2021-11-0730.8
Observed price2021-11-1932.3
Observed price2021-12-0129.6
Observed price2021-12-0931.3
Observed price2022-01-0233.0
Observed price2022-01-1030.6
Observed price2022-01-1429.7
Observed price2022-01-2627.4
Observed price2022-02-0728.2
Observed price2022-02-2326.1
Observed price2022-03-0723.4
Observed price2022-03-1925.9
Observed price2022-03-2725.3
Observed price2022-04-0426.2
Observed price2022-04-2025.9
Observed price2022-05-1022.4
Observed price2022-05-2221.1
Observed price2022-06-0327.1
Observed price2022-06-1525.6
Observed price2022-06-2729.0
Observed price2022-07-0130.6
Observed price2022-07-2133.1
Observed price2022-07-2532.5
Observed price2022-08-1437.5
Observed price2022-08-3037.5
Observed price2022-09-0739.0
Observed price2022-09-1540.4
Observed price2022-09-2737.5
Observed price2022-10-0939.0
Observed price2022-10-2543.4
Observed price2022-11-0241.7
Observed price2022-11-1854.9
Observed price2022-12-0854.2
Observed price2022-12-1255.3
Observed price2022-12-2053.8
Observed price2023-01-0557.0
Observed price2023-01-1350.7
Observed price2023-01-2957.1
Observed price2023-02-0267.3
Observed price2023-02-1473.8
Observed price2023-03-0274.7
Observed price2023-03-1070.7
Observed price2023-03-2274.8
Observed price2023-04-1184.2
Observed price2023-04-2394.5
Observed price2023-05-0588.4
Observed price2023-05-0986.5
Observed price2023-05-29105
Observed price2023-06-14104
Observed price2023-06-22113
Observed price2023-06-26107
Observed price2023-07-16118
Observed price2023-07-20113
Observed price2023-08-09132
Observed price2023-08-21118
Observed price2023-09-02136
Observed price2023-09-10135
Observed price2023-09-22105
Observed price2023-09-30110
Observed price2023-10-0499.5
Observed price2023-10-24110
Observed price2023-11-0194.5
Observed price2023-11-21112
Observed price2023-12-07126
Observed price2023-12-11130
Observed price2023-12-19146
Observed price2024-01-04135
Observed price2024-01-16164
Observed price2024-01-28159
Observed price2024-02-09175
Observed price2024-02-21177
Observed price2024-02-29211
Observed price2024-03-24202
Observed price2024-04-05161
Observed price2024-04-13165
Observed price2024-04-25176
Observed price2024-05-19159
Observed price2024-05-23185
Observed price2024-06-08181
Observed price2024-06-16197
Observed price2024-06-28211
Observed price2024-07-06202
Observed price2024-07-14198
Observed price2024-08-03170
Observed price2024-08-07186
Observed price2024-08-15152
Observed price2024-08-31147
Observed price2024-09-20113
Observed price2024-10-06105
Observed price2024-10-14115
Observed price2024-11-03105
Observed price2024-11-07116
Observed price2024-11-11134
Observed price2024-11-15121
Observed price2024-12-09138
Observed price2024-12-21129
Observed price2025-01-10125
Observed price2025-01-14131
Observed price2025-01-22118
Observed price2025-02-1174.5
Observed price2025-02-2373.9
Observed price2025-03-0363.8
Observed price2025-03-1169.5
Observed price2025-03-3162.8
Observed price2025-04-1650.0
Observed price2025-04-2459.0
Observed price2025-04-2861.9
Observed price2025-05-1879.2
Observed price2025-05-2281.5
Observed price2025-06-11125
Observed price2025-06-23121
Observed price2025-07-01127
Observed price2025-07-13108
Observed price2025-07-25121
Observed price2025-08-10109
Observed price2025-08-18124
Observed price2025-08-26115
Observed price2025-09-15141
Observed price2025-09-19144
Observed price2025-09-27130
Observed price2025-10-17134
Observed price2025-11-02121
Observed price2025-11-0695.8
Observed price2025-11-2270.6
Observed price2025-11-3075.2
Observed price2025-12-0481.6
Observed price2026-01-0176.2
Observed price2026-01-1387.6
Observed price2026-01-2191.3
Observed price2026-02-0676.3
Observed price2026-02-1075.6
Observed price2026-02-2694.7
Observed price2026-03-0682.4
Observed price2026-03-2666.9
Observed price2026-03-3059.4
Observed price2026-04-1569.1
Observed price2026-04-2365.9
Observed price2026-05-1355.6
Observed price2026-05-2151.8
Observed price2026-05-2956.0
Observed price2026-06-1058.1
Observed price2026-06-3074.0
Observed price2026-07-0874.2
Observed price2026-07-2079.7
Observed price2026-08-0182.8
Observed price2026-08-0996.3
Observed price2026-09-02107
Observed price2026-09-1095.8
Observed price2026-09-1896.4
Observed price2026-09-22102
Observed price2026-09-2599.5
Published advisor forecast2026-09-1896.4
Published advisor forecast2026-12-1890.7
Published advisor forecast2027-03-1897.9
Published advisor forecast2027-06-1894.0
Published advisor forecast2027-09-18101
Published advisor forecast2027-12-18105
Published advisor forecast2028-03-18108
Published advisor forecast2028-06-18102
Published advisor forecast2028-09-18108
Published advisor forecast2028-12-18112
Published advisor forecast2029-03-18116
Published advisor forecast2029-06-18113
Published advisor forecast2029-09-18118
Published advisor forecast2029-12-18122
Published advisor forecast2030-03-18124
Published advisor forecast2030-06-18121
Published advisor forecast2030-09-18127
Published advisor forecast2030-12-18130
Published advisor forecast2031-03-18133
Published advisor forecast2031-06-18130
Published advisor forecast2031-09-18136

2. Scenarios & Signals

Bull case

The bull case activates when European sell-through proves rhode is a global franchise rather than a US moment, and the core brand's price rollbacks restore units without permanently resetting margin. Those two must happen together: rhode supplies growth while the core supplies cash and shelf credibility. Sephora then overtakes Amazon in retail mix, prestige pricing lifts consolidated margin above 21%, and estimates for FY2030 move toward $8 of adjusted on a re-expanded multiple.

Bear case

The bear case begins the moment the refund-flattered comparison arrives and underlying lands in the sixties. A weakening core, defended only by price cuts, meets a rhode rollout that fills doors faster than it fills baskets. Marketing spend rises to defend both, slips below 19%, and a 27x multiple on falling estimates unwinds violently — exactly the mechanism that took the stock from $150.99 to $52.35 in twelve months [16].

Current crowd narrative

The crowd has decided rhode is a settled and the August guidance raise proved the drawdown was an overreaction. Shares doubled from $52 to near the $102 sell-side average, with targets spanning $65 to $127. What is treated as fact: 18-20% growth is the new run-rate. The anchoring bias is mistaking a one-off tariff refund for durable earnings power.

Alpha-gap assessment

No convincing gap exists at $96.40 — the two errors roughly cancel. The crowd overestimates near-term earnings durability, because roughly 1,050bps of Q1's 83% was a non-recurring tariff refund [2] and headline TTM of $1.00 is simultaneously distorted by earnout remeasurement. Yet it underestimates rhode's multi-year shelf runway, still under 40% of Sephora doors after Europe [9]. Fair value clusters near the current price with unusually fat tails on both sides.

Convergence catalyst

The Q2 FY2027 report, expected early November 2026, is the first clean quarter without IEEPA refunds and the first including rhode Europe. Underlying ex-refund is the tell. The first observable repricing sign: whether management holds the $401-407 million guide without leaning on the windfall.

Complete advisor preview locked

Unlock this report and every AI Advisor

Sign in to check your access, or upgrade to the Base plan to read this report and open every advisor.