Skip to main content
Assets
Bayerische Motoren Werke logo
BMW.FRA
Bayerische Motoren Werke
Consumer Discretionary · Automobile Manufacturers

German luxury vehicle and motorcycle manufacturer known for performance, innovation, and premium automotive engineering excellence.

HQ: GermanyListed: Germany

Historical AI Opinions

Audit every published iPulse AI forecast batch and immutable historical research document for Bayerische Motoren Werke.

Bayerische Motoren Werke AG (BMW.FRA) AI OPINIONS & ADVISOR ANALYSIS

Read and compare the 14 individual AI Advisor deep-dive reports, including their forecast paths, ratings, price targets, and reasoning.

Updated on 20 September 2026Deep analysis 20 September 2026

25 min readAudit All Past Forecasts

1. Investment Thesis — Base Case

The central tension is whether €61 already pays for a permanent loss of the China profit pool. The evidence says the market has priced permanence into a situation containing substantial temporary components: restructuring and tariff charges worth roughly 250 basis points sit inside a 1-3% guided corridor [3][11], while €1bn of annual savings arrives from 2028 [9]. China will not return to a third of deliveries, but Europe already overtook it [7], and volume scales into 2028. Investors buy a depressed cyclical at 0.39 times book with the cash flow to keep shrinking its own share count.

  • Normalised Automotive EBIT margin near 6% by 2029 implies group net income recovering toward €8-9bn.
  • At 8 times recovered earnings on roughly 650m total shares, that supports €95-105 per ordinary share.
  • Cross-check: even 0.55 times current , well below the decade norm, exceeds €85.

Historical prices and published forecast

Historical prices and published forecastObserved prices and the selected advisor's published projection share a split-adjusted price basis. Prices after the forecast start are later observations, not information known at publication. Forecasts are uncertain. Values in EUR.50.2167.4584.69101.93119.17Sep 2021Mar 2024Sep 2026Mar 2029Sep 2031Forecast starts
  • Observed price
  • Published advisor forecast
Observed prices and the selected advisor's published projection share a split-adjusted price basis. Prices after the forecast start are later observations, not information known at publication. Forecasts are uncertain. Values in EUR.
View chart values
Historical prices and published forecast — published chart values
SeriesDateValue (EUR)
Observed price2021-09-1482.1
Observed price2021-09-1880.3
Observed price2021-10-0183.8
Observed price2021-10-1085.4
Observed price2021-10-3188.4
Observed price2021-11-2194.5
Observed price2021-11-2685.8
Observed price2021-12-0990.4
Observed price2021-12-1787.0
Observed price2021-12-2689.0
Observed price2022-01-1298.8
Observed price2022-01-2095.7
Observed price2022-02-0692.1
Observed price2022-02-1593.0
Observed price2022-03-0871.2
Observed price2022-03-1274.5
Observed price2022-03-2979.0
Observed price2022-04-1176.4
Observed price2022-04-2079.7
Observed price2022-05-0380.0
Observed price2022-05-1577.7
Observed price2022-06-0683.0
Observed price2022-06-1477.5
Observed price2022-06-2377.5
Observed price2022-07-0173.0
Observed price2022-07-1875.8
Observed price2022-07-3178.0
Observed price2022-08-1378.4
Observed price2022-09-0373.1
Observed price2022-09-1674.8
Observed price2022-09-2970.0
Observed price2022-10-0371.2
Observed price2022-10-2578.7
Observed price2022-11-0277.0
Observed price2022-11-1184.5
Observed price2022-12-0285.4
Observed price2022-12-1582.8
Observed price2022-12-1983.7
Observed price2023-01-0991.2
Observed price2023-01-1890.4
Observed price2023-02-0496.8
Observed price2023-02-1298.0
Observed price2023-03-0299.6
Observed price2023-03-06101
Observed price2023-03-1495.7
Observed price2023-04-0599.4
Observed price2023-04-13103
Observed price2023-05-09109
Observed price2023-05-13100.0
Observed price2023-05-26103
Observed price2023-06-12110
Observed price2023-06-16112
Observed price2023-07-08108
Observed price2023-07-25109
Observed price2023-08-02104
Observed price2023-08-06103
Observed price2023-08-2896.6
Observed price2023-09-0594.9
Observed price2023-09-1899.3
Observed price2023-10-0595.7
Observed price2023-10-1498.5
Observed price2023-10-2688.5
Observed price2023-11-1393.6
Observed price2023-11-2593.8
Observed price2023-12-08101
Observed price2023-12-17101
Observed price2023-12-2199.4
Observed price2024-01-07100
Observed price2024-01-2093.1
Observed price2024-02-0297.6
Observed price2024-02-23106
Observed price2024-03-02109
Observed price2024-03-15106
Observed price2024-03-24105
Observed price2024-04-06113
Observed price2024-04-27107
Observed price2024-05-05102
Observed price2024-05-14103
Observed price2024-06-0492.1
Observed price2024-06-0991.2
Observed price2024-06-1387.7
Observed price2024-07-0487.5
Observed price2024-07-1791.3
Observed price2024-07-3086.3
Observed price2024-08-1279.7
Observed price2024-08-2484.7
Observed price2024-09-1072.1
Observed price2024-09-1975.5
Observed price2024-09-2879.1
Observed price2024-10-1575.5
Observed price2024-11-0571.8
Observed price2024-11-1366.5
Observed price2024-12-0171.6
Observed price2024-12-0575.0
Observed price2024-12-1379.7
Observed price2025-01-0479.6
Observed price2025-01-1276.1
Observed price2025-02-0776.6
Observed price2025-02-1582.5
Observed price2025-02-2082.1
Observed price2025-02-2485.4
Observed price2025-03-1784.8
Observed price2025-04-0863.5
Observed price2025-04-1267.7
Observed price2025-04-2976.1
Observed price2025-05-1282.7
Observed price2025-05-2477.0
Observed price2025-06-0677.2
Observed price2025-06-2372.1
Observed price2025-06-2873.7
Observed price2025-07-1583.6
Observed price2025-08-0183.7
Observed price2025-08-1489.0
Observed price2025-08-2290.8
Observed price2025-09-0885.1
Observed price2025-09-1783.3
Observed price2025-10-0488.3
Observed price2025-10-0882.3
Observed price2025-10-1279.2
Observed price2025-11-0380.6
Observed price2025-11-1189.0
Observed price2025-11-2888.3
Observed price2025-12-0795.7
Observed price2026-01-0193.6
Observed price2026-01-1488.8
Observed price2026-01-2787.5
Observed price2026-02-0989.3
Observed price2026-02-1789.9
Observed price2026-03-0680.8
Observed price2026-03-1180.9
Observed price2026-03-1975.2
Observed price2026-04-1883.3
Observed price2026-04-2779.8
Observed price2026-05-0981.3
Observed price2026-05-1874.7
Observed price2026-05-2677.1
Observed price2026-06-1762.0
Observed price2026-06-2161.3
Observed price2026-06-3057.2
Observed price2026-07-2557.4
Observed price2026-07-2960.4
Observed price2026-08-2458.2
Observed price2026-08-2862.4
Observed price2026-09-1463.3
Observed price2026-09-2358.1
Observed price2026-09-2456.9
Observed price2026-09-2556.0
Published advisor forecast2026-09-1861.2
Published advisor forecast2026-12-1863.1
Published advisor forecast2027-03-1860.6
Published advisor forecast2027-06-1864.2
Published advisor forecast2027-09-1866.1
Published advisor forecast2027-12-1868.8
Published advisor forecast2028-03-1872.2
Published advisor forecast2028-06-1873.6
Published advisor forecast2028-09-1871.4
Published advisor forecast2028-12-1874.3
Published advisor forecast2029-03-1876.5
Published advisor forecast2029-06-1878.0
Published advisor forecast2029-09-1876.5
Published advisor forecast2029-12-1878.8
Published advisor forecast2030-03-1881.1
Published advisor forecast2030-06-1882.0
Published advisor forecast2030-09-1880.3
Published advisor forecast2030-12-1882.7
Published advisor forecast2031-03-1884.4
Published advisor forecast2031-06-1885.2
Published advisor forecast2031-09-1886.9

2. Scenarios & Signals

Bull case

The bull case activates when two clocks align: deliveries scaling just as the restructuring charge drops out of the run rate. Chinese volume stabilises during 2027, European share gains hold, and the 2028 cost base is €1bn lighter — so margin recovers faster than volume. That combination flips the narrative from to , and the multiple does the heavy lifting, moving from 0.39 times book toward 0.6. Buybacks at trough prices amplify every point of recovery per share.

Bear case

The bear case activates if the China exports itself to Europe. Chinese premium brands localise European assembly during 2028-2030, BMW's defensive stronghold turns competitive, and erodes in the one region still generating contribution. Weak volume then collides with elevated , negative group cash conversion and a captive lender absorbing residual-value losses on returning combustion vehicles. The dividend is cut, the buyback stops, income holders exit, and the shares trade as a structurally impaired manufacturer rather than a cyclical at a trough.

Current crowd narrative

The consensus treats BMW as a melting ice cube: China is gone forever, tariffs are permanent, and the 1-3% margin corridor is the new normal rather than a trough containing two one-off charges. DZ Bank's cut to Hold with a €65 target and a six-year-low share price show anchoring on the last datapoint [6]. Nobody is paid to buy German autos here.

Alpha-gap assessment

The crowd underestimates these shares, and the blind spot is definitional. The printed 1-3% Automotive EBIT corridor already absorbs up to 125 basis points of restructuring plus roughly 125 basis points of tariff [3][11], so underlying margin is closer to 4-5% — the headline flatters the collapse. Separately, group of negative €2.73bn is a captive-receivable artefact, not ; Automotive is guided above €2.5bn [12]. Screens punish both numbers indiscriminately.

Convergence catalyst

The Q3 2026 print in early November, followed by March 2027 full-year guidance, is the recognition moment. If the 1-3% corridor holds at its upper end with China sequentially stabilising, the permanent-impairment narrative loses its evidence. First observable sign: the discount to book narrowing from 0.39 toward 0.45 on rising volume.

Complete advisor preview locked

Unlock this report and every AI Advisor

Sign in to check your access, or upgrade to the Base plan to read this report and open every advisor.