EP 31 | Adyen Stock Analysis: Will It Make Investors Rich? Published: 2026-10-26T16:27:15Z Reviewed: 2026-10-26T13:44:56.509117+00:00 Complete selected 248-segment transcript and all 318 token-timed caption cues read by Codex AI parent, with whole-media decoding, source/numeric and sampled visual checks. No human, independent-agent or full uninterrupted listening/perfect aural verification claimed. Caption proper-name normalization is not phonetic proof. Upstream manual/source-display QA remains open; primary facts independently checked. Published RSS transcode full decoded correlation 0.9998324574036904 with zero lag. See package final-qa.json for documented limits. [0:00] Adyen stock. Will it make investors rich? The interesting question is how much [0:05] lasting cash [0:06] reaches shareholders after computing investment, acquisitions, and merchant [0:10] settlement obligations. [0:11] Welcome to AI Investment Edge, episode 31. Right out of the gate for you, let's just [0:16] lay down the [0:17] current evidence-weighted consensus rating. So for Adyen, it's actually a buy [0:23] at both its one-year [0:24] and five-year horizons. Okay. Got it. Yeah. And that comes with an immediate buy and [0:29] keep platform [0:30] label. Now we check these ratings on October 26th using the October 23 price [0:34] basis. Right. But, [0:36] you know, we always have to remind everyone, these are platform research [0:39] labels, right? Not [0:41] personal trade commands. Exactly. Right. I mean, to have a real long-term thesis, you [0:46] need both a [0:47] sensible purchase valuation and, frankly, the company actually executing [0:50] successfully. Yeah. [0:52] Which is a big gift sometimes. So before we dive into the heavy math, let's just [0:56] clarify what Adyen [0:58] actually does because it's, well, it's kind of in the background of everything we do. [1:02] It really is. It's a Netherlands-based payments infrastructure company, [1:06] mostly serving large merchants and software platforms. [1:09] Basically, it seamlessly connects [1:11] online and in-store payments, payment authorization, risk tools, acquiring, and [1:15] settlement all through one [1:17] single integrated platform. Which is huge for these massive global companies. [1:21] Right. [1:22] Merchants basically pay for processing and related services across three pillars, [1:27] which are digital, [1:29] unified commerce, and platforms. And, you know, while you might see their payment [1:33] terminals at a store, [1:35] like that visible tip of the iceberg, the real value is their massive software and [1:39] banking infrastructure. [1:41] Yeah. That infrastructure layer is key. I mean, if you remember our previous Apple [1:45] conversation on this [1:46] show, we talked about how Apple offers the wallet, right? [1:49] The actual device interface. [1:51] Right. The part you tap. Exactly. Adyen is operating in a totally different layer. [1:56] They provide the merchant acquiring plumbing underneath it all. [1:59] So they don't compete with Apple. They just [2:01] coexist. Okay. So they're the plumbing. Let's look at how much water is actually [2:05] flowing through those [2:07] pipes. Because looking at the first half of 2026, their process payments were [2:12] up 24% reported. [2:14] That's about 804 billion euros. It's a massive number. [2:17] It is. But then net revenue was only up 19% [2:21] reported or 21% at constant currency, which is about 1.3 billion euros. [2:26] Right. [2:27] So wait, volume grew by 24%, but constant currency revenue only grew by [2:33] 21%. Why is the volume growing [2:36] faster than the revenue? Are they just, you know, losing their pricing power? [2:39] So that is actually the massive debate right now. [2:41] And we have to split this into two parts. First, [2:45] it's a known fact that volume tiering and merchant mix contribute to a lower blended [2:50] fee rate. [2:50] Like a bulk discount. Precisely. When a huge, you know, non-exclusive global [2:55] merchant, someone like [2:56] a major streaming service or a rideshare company pushes billions through Adyen, they [3:00] get a cheaper per [3:02] transaction rate. That makes sense. Yeah. So as that top tier volume explodes, the [3:06] average revenue they [3:07] squeeze out of each transaction naturally shrinks. [3:10] That's just mix. But the second part is an open [3:13] question. Which is what? How much does commercial pricing pressure also contribute [3:17] to that lower yield? [3:18] I mean, competitors are constantly trying to undercut them. [3:21] And it's important to remember [3:22] both of these things can coexist. It isn't just mix. [3:26] But regardless of what's causing it, [3:28] that 21% revenue growth has to remain profitable. [3:31] Okay. So let's talk about that profitability. [3:34] Their first half EBITDA was around 642 million euros. [3:38] That's a 49% margin. Right. But their actual [3:41] operating margin is 43%. So where's that missing 6% going? [3:46] Huh. So that gap is almost [3:48] entirely depreciation and amortization. It's roughly 77 million euros. [3:53] Just from wear and tear? Exactly. Wear and tear on their massive data centers and [3:57] hardware. So if you take that 642 million in EBITDA and subtract the 77 million in [4:03] depreciation and amortization, [4:05] you're left with about 564 million in actual operating profit. [4:10] Got it. But they also have finance income boosting things, right? [4:14] They do. Yeah. About 143 million euros in broad finance income. [4:19] But, and this is crucial, notice where that sits on the income statement. [4:23] It sits below both operating profit and EBITDA. [4:27] So it juices the net earnings. Exactly. It boosts net earnings. [4:31] But you can't rely on it forever. And this is exactly why a management's long-term [4:35] goal, which is hitting above 55% by 2028, that is specifically an [4:40] EBITDA margin goal. [4:42] Oh, interesting. [4:43] Yeah. It is not a guaranteed operating margin outcome. [4:46] Net earnings can really depend on that finance income, which fluctuates. [4:51] Okay. Let's pivot to the balance sheet. Because they reported cash at June 30 of [4:56] 12.4 billion euros, which sounds incredible. [5:00] But thinking back to our previous PayPal conversation on the show, we have to [5:03] separate client funds from corporate cash, right? [5:06] Yes. That is the exact same dynamic here. Out of that 12.4 billion, about 8.1 [5:11] billion euros is owed directly to merchants. [5:14] Wow. Okay. So it's not even theirs. [5:17] Right. It is not shareholder cash. It's just sitting in the register waiting to be [5:20] paid out. [5:21] So if you adjust for that and factor in merchant receivables, it leaves them with [5:26] about 4.9 billion euros in actual corporate cash. [5:29] Okay. That's a big haircut from 12 billion. [5:32] Yeah. And if we look at it pro forma net of their recent acquisitions, it's roughly 4.6 [5:37] billion euros. [5:38] And what about liabilities? [5:40] Well, their total current assets are roughly 14 billion euros and current [5:43] liabilities are about 8.5 billion. So that gives them a current ratio of about 1.6. [5:49] Which seems pretty healthy. [5:51] It is, but you have to remember that lease obligations and strict regulatory capital [5:55] requirements still remain. [5:57] They can't just spend all of that cash freely. [5:59] Speaking of spending, let's look at their investment intensity. [6:03] Their first half company defined CapEx was about 64 million euros. [6:08] That's like 5% of net revenue. [6:10] Right. But I saw their full year plan is around 7%. [6:14] Why the sudden jump in the second half? [6:16] Basically, management decided to pull forward some 2027 data center purchases. [6:21] Into the second half of 2026. [6:24] Oh, so they're front loading it. [6:26] Exactly. Which, you know, brings up a good point. [6:28] Kind of like our previous Amazon conversation. [6:30] Yeah. Where the heavy spending isn't inherently bad. [6:33] As long as the demand pays off eventually. [6:35] Right. The question isn't just about the spending itself. [6:38] It's about what that growing demand actually earns after the heavy investment [6:42] bill is paid. [6:44] Management expects investment intensity to decline later on, but we have to treat that [6:48] as an expectation to be tested. [6:51] It's not a guaranteed end to costs. [6:53] Exactly. So to test it, let's look at one clear cash bridge. [6:57] Okay. Walk me through it. [6:59] You start with that roughly 642 million in EBITDA. [7:03] You subtract the 64 million in CapEx and about 24 million in lease principal. [7:09] Okay. And that leaves you with roughly 553 million euros in free cash before cash [7:14] taxes and working capital movements. [7:17] Wait, but their statutory operating cash flow was massive, right? [7:21] Like 2.3 billion euros. [7:23] Yes. And you definitely shouldn't ignore statutory cash flow. [7:27] But you have to reconcile the movements. [7:29] That 2.3 billion includes approximately 1.7 billion of merchant payable [7:34] settlement inflow. [7:36] Oh, so again, that's just the merchant money sloshing around. [7:40] Exactly. [7:41] That settlement inflow is not shareholder cash. [7:44] You have to strip it out to see what the business actually generated for investors. [7:48] Okay. So with that real cash number in mind, let's talk valuation. [7:52] To get the trailing 12-month profit, we just count each half once, right? [7:56] Right. So second half of 2025 was roughly 582 million. [8:01] Plus the first half of 2026 at 544 million. [8:05] That gives us a trailing profit of roughly 1.13 billion euros. [8:09] Which, at the dated reference price, gives you a PE of roughly 27. [8:14] A PE of 27. [8:15] And for you listening, I really want to stress this. [8:19] Do not fall for these AI narratives online. [8:21] They keep repeating fake low teens multiples for Adyen. [8:24] Yeah, that's a huge trap. [8:26] Right. [8:26] Because some of these models accidentally duplicate the semi-annual data, and it [8:29] literally cuts the PE in half. [8:31] You have to use the real math. [8:33] Yeah. A PE of 27 is the reality. [8:35] So let's look at what that means for the actual stock price scenarios moving [8:39] forward. [8:40] Let's do it. [8:41] And just to be clear, we are leading with the dated October 23 reference price of [8:45] about 945 euros. [8:47] So this is not a live Monday quote. [8:49] Right. So assuming zero ordinary cash dividends at both horizons, our fixed [8:55] endpoints are third quarter 2027 and third quarter 2031. [9:00] Okay. And what are the targets? [9:01] The weighted base endpoint for 2027 is roughly 1,108 euros. [9:07] Which is about 17% cumulative appreciation. [9:10] Exactly. And for 2031, the base endpoint is about 2,193 euros, [9:16] which implies roughly a 132% cumulative price [9:20] appreciation. [9:22] Okay. Those are serious numbers. [9:24] What actually drives the bull and bear cases for those targets? [9:27] Well, the bull case really requires them to sustain merchant expansion, drive useful [9:32] cross-selling, and crucially, that heavy investment intensity has to actually ease [9:38] up. And the bear case? [9:39] The bear case happens if we see weaker demand, rising infrastructure costs, lower [9:44] interest income, and frankly, valuation compression. [9:48] If the market just decides a PE of 27 is too expensive. [9:53] Right. [9:54] So looking at the practical market forces, the four quadrants, what are the ordinary [9:58] drivers and frictions acting on this? [10:01] For ordinary drivers, it's about capturing more wallet share from existing merchants, [10:06] deeper integration, and pushing more platforms flow. [10:09] And the frictions? [10:11] The frictions are the massive bargaining power of their large customers, heavy [10:15] regulation, and just brutal competition. [10:18] Okay. But what about the wild cards? [10:20] Like the distinct upside tail? [10:22] The distinct upside tail is super interesting. [10:24] It's the idea of machine-to-machine and agent-directed commerce becoming a [10:28] substantial new payment channel. [10:31] Like AI agents buying things on our behalf. [10:34] Exactly. [10:35] Or alternatively, a massive unexpected migration away from legacy systems. [10:40] But, and this is a big but, this is a highly speculative scenario. [10:44] It is not a confirmed contract. [10:46] Got it. [10:47] And what's the distinct downside tail? [10:49] That would be a prolonged outage or a massive security breach of their integrated [10:53] stack. [10:54] Something that just shatters trust. [10:56] Or a major shift to alternative payment rails that just bypasses them entirely. [11:01] Wow. Okay. [11:02] But we need to keep those extreme conditional tails strictly separate from [11:06] just ordinary business fluctuations. [11:08] Absolutely. [11:09] So, considering all these risks and rewards, where is the market actually [11:13] mispricing, Adyen? [11:14] Where is the alpha gap? [11:17] The core research hypothesis here is that investors might be mistaking the lower [11:21] blended payment basis points and that front-loaded investment for a permanently [11:25] weakening business. [11:26] So, it brings us right back to our earlier debate. [11:29] We know the mix and tiering causes compression. [11:32] But the open question is how much actual pricing pressure exists. [11:36] And because they coexist, the market might be misinterpreting it. [11:39] Precisely. [11:40] But the counter-argument is that the market is actually completely correct to demand a [11:44] discount. [11:44] You know, because of that pricing power risk, their sensitivity to rates, and the [11:48] massive future spending they need to do. [11:51] Do the AI models agree on this alpha gap? [11:54] Definitely not. [11:55] I mean, we have 14 AI research contributions spanning nine frameworks and [12:00] three models, and they fiercely disagree. [12:03] What are they disagreeing on specifically? [12:05] They disagree on how much of that fee compression is just mix versus actual [12:09] pricing pressure. [12:10] They disagree on whether the investment will actually moderate. [12:14] And they disagree on how fast their software acquisitions will actually earn [12:18] their cost. [12:18] But even with all that disagreement, the public-weighted rating is still a buy in [12:23] both horizons. [12:24] Yes. But keep in mind, that is distinct from individual strong buy opinions. [12:29] Right. So, what does the actual quarterly path look like to hit those 2027 targets? [12:34] So, the first forecast checkpoint in the fourth quarter, 2026, is actually about [12:39] €920. [12:40] Wait, really? [12:42] That's roughly 2.7% below the current reference price. [12:46] It dips first. [12:47] Yeah, the models project a near-term dip as the market digests that heavy front-loaded [12:52] CapEx. [12:53] But that's followed by a first quarter 2027 recovery near €976. [12:58] Okay. But again, these forecast windows are not confirmed company events. [13:02] Speaking of which, what are the actual real events we should be watching? [13:06] Well, the very next confirmed event is their Q3 business update on October 28th. [13:11] Which is just two days after we're recording this. [13:13] So, obviously, we are not going to invent results. [13:16] Right. Exactly. [13:17] And after that, the full H2 results won't be out until February 2027. [13:22] Okay. So, looking back a bit, how has this analysis shifted over the last few months? [13:27] Like, comparing the prior batch of research to now? [13:30] It shifted a lot. [13:31] The July view leaned heavily on expecting a harvest period after a ton of hiring, plus [13:35] relying on interest income and a cheap value re-rating. [13:39] And September? [13:40] The September view refocuses entirely on the platforms mix, the higher near-term [13:45] CapEx, software integration, and looking for actual proof of cash quality. [13:51] Oh, so there were real business changes driving this, not just panel score changes. [13:55] Yes, exactly. [13:57] For instance, their August guidance actually raised their 2026 constant [14:01] currency growth to between 21 and 23 percent. [14:04] That's a good sign. [14:05] And they had some acquisitions too, right? [14:08] Yeah, they closed on Talon.One for 750 million euros and Orb for [14:13] 335 million US dollars. [14:16] Oh, wow. Big deals. [14:17] Yeah. And both of those closed on July 1, which means it was after the H1 period. [14:22] Also, both deals included Adyen shares. [14:25] And that 6 million euro expense we saw in H1, that was just transaction costs, not [14:29] consolidated operations. [14:31] Got it. And there was some leadership shakeup too. [14:34] Right. CPO Gayathri Rajan became effective July 1, and interim CFO Hwa Tsao became [14:40] effective September 1. [14:42] It's important to keep those dates separate. [14:44] Definitely. [14:45] Now, bringing up our last public stock baseline from episode 30, which was [14:49] Palantir, the contrast here is crazy. [14:51] Oh, completely different. [14:52] Yeah. [14:53] Palantir was a debate about an attractive software business versus the massive price [14:57] paid for future growth. [14:58] Adyen's payments economics and its capital requirements are just a completely [15:02] different animal. [15:03] They require a totally different analytical lens. [15:06] So wrap this up for us. [15:07] What would prove this entire deep dive wrong? [15:09] What's the invalidation? [15:11] You should challenge the bull case if their organic growth disappoints, if fee yield [15:15] falls without profitable volume to make up for it, or if net earnings rely too heavily [15:20] on finance income. [15:21] And to invalidate the bear case? [15:23] Challenge the bear case if revenue growth, cash quality, and merchant expansion stay [15:27] strong, while that investment intensity actually moderates like management says it [15:31] will. Right. [15:32] So a conditional synthesis for you listening. [15:35] Adyen could compound substantial investor wealth, but only if profitable commerce [15:40] growth and disciplined reinvestment support the targets. [15:44] It's all about execution and actual cash economics. [15:47] It is not a guaranteed rising line, and it is definitely not a fabricated low [15:52] multiple. [15:53] That's exactly it. [15:55] Well, we naturally invite you to inspect Adyen's AI consensus, the individual AI [15:59] opinions, and the profile and fundamentals on iPulse AI. [16:04] And just to recap, we mentioned our own previous conversations on PayPal, Apple, [16:08] and Amazon today, and we used Palantir as our last talk baseline. [16:12] Please remember to like, comment, and subscribe. [16:15] Thanks for tuning in. [16:16] We are publishing a new podcast every day of the week, except Thursday. [16:20] Stay tuned for the next podcast on AXA. [16:23] How does an insurer turn underwriting and invested premiums into shareholder value?